• Medicine
  • Astronomy
  • Sociology
  • Technology
  • Spirituality
  • History
  • Open Access
  • News

New Research Finds That The Majority Rule Is Best For Group Evaluation

Crowdsourcing is a method of addressing a problem or a difficulty by enlisting the help of a large number of individuals. The introduction and widespread usage of social networks has expanded the variety of possible crowdsourcing applications since new internet technologies may now include many individuals in completing a particular activity. Crowdsourcing may be considered a subset of cooperative behavior, and as such, it can be investigated utilizing Game Theory and evolutionary dynamics.

Daniele Vilone of Italy's National Research Council's Institute of Cognitive Science and Technology demonstrated, using a game-theoretical, evolutionary approach, that in most cases, the majority rule is best for group evaluation, even when the agents are not the best experts on the topic at hand. The research project was partially funded by the Horizon 2020 Research and Innovationprogram of the European Union. He also demonstrated that noise might impair the procedure's efficiency in non-trivial conditions.

Application Of Majority Rule Algorithm

The researcher studied a case in which several specialists had stated their judgments on a specific issue, and a final decision had to be reached based on such evaluations. Similar scenarios happen now in which professionals do not engage only in evaluation procedures. Citizen Science and crowdsourcing may now be performed with the involvement of non-professional volunteers through social networks. The emphasis of this study was on the case of a natural catastrophe and the requirement to analyze the existence of damages based solely on a photo exhibiting damage delivered to a group of individuals who provided their evaluation. A final, definitive group evaluation must be presented at some point.

A group of individuals is shown an image. Each group member must assess the extent of damage depicted in the picture by assigning it a note, a number ranging from 0 to 4. As a result, the group's rating is based on the assessments of the individuals. A task is a basic procedure of analyzing an image as a group. The majority rule was utilized as an algorithm for each job; the majority rule was susceptible to noise for a non-trivial subset of the model parameters, especially when the groups were pretty big but not the system. If confirmed by further research, this algorithm could serve as a valuable warning to users of this crowdsourcing tool: a simple majority rule, while theoretically very effective in comparison to other procedures, can provide misleading responses when the groups are significant but not numerous, and, more broadly, when the groups are substantial but not numerous.

What Are The Advantages Of Majority Rule?

The majority rule is a decision rule that picks options with a majority or more than half of the votes. It is the most often employed binary decision rule in influential decision-making organisations, including all legislatures of democratic states. In many modern liberal democracies, majority rule is the norm. It is commonly used in legislatures and other bodies where options can be discussed and revised in a deliberative process until the final form of a proposal is approved or rejected by majority rule. The decision rule handles each voter the same way. It makes no difference who casts a vote when majority rule is used; the voter's identity is not even required. Neutrality: The decision rule gives equal weight to each alternative.

Disadvantages Of Majority Rule

Some claim that majority rule might result in inadequate deliberation or even "an aggressive culture and conflict." Along these lines, some argue that the majority rule fails to account for the strength of preferences. The authors of An Anarchist Critique of Democracy, for example, suggest that "two votes who are casually interested in doing anything" can beat one voter who has "dire objection" to the two's idea. Cycling, according to voting theorists, causes chronic instability. According to Buchanan and Tullock, unanimity is the only decision norm that ensures economic efficiency.

Supermajority rules are frequently employed in binary issues where a favourable decision weighs more than a negative. A positive choice is made under the usual definition of special majority voting if a considerable part of the votes cast favour that decision—for example, two-thirds or three-fourths. For instance, in the United States, jury judgments must be supported by at least 10 of the 12 jurors, if not unanimously. This supermajoritarian idea stems directly from the assumption of innocence, which underpins the US judicial system. "The more the debates are essential and serious, the more the view that carries should approach unanimity," Rousseau stated of supermajority voting on critical choices.

Conclusion

The group evaluation is the evaluation of the majority members. The researcher determined that the majority rule is preferable for group evaluation in most scenarios. However, noise (i.e., fortuitous errors, misunderstanding, or any other source of non-deterministic results) might impair the procedure's efficiency in non-trivial situations. As a result, to make the process as reliable as possible, the presence of noise and its effects must be carefully considered.

Comments (0 comments)

    Recent Articles

    • What Is My Angel Number? Number That Feels Spiritually Significant

      What Is My Angel Number? Number That Feels Spiritually Significant

      What Is My Angel Number - Your angel number is a spiritually important number for you. It's usually a number associated with your name or birthdate. It might also be a series of numbers that you see continually throughout time.

    • Music Origin - Overview From Begining To Present Day

      Music Origin - Overview From Begining To Present Day

      Music origin is likely to have occurred in Syria about 3400 years ago.

    • Instructions For Authors - A Step-by-Step Guide For Submitting A Scientific Paper

      Instructions For Authors - A Step-by-Step Guide For Submitting A Scientific Paper

      The instructions for authors are a unique set of criteria for each journal.

    • Peer Review - An Overview Of The Process, Benefits, And Pitfalls

      Peer Review - An Overview Of The Process, Benefits, And Pitfalls

      You will get information about our comprehensive, productive, and open-minded peer review process.

    • Alpha Brain – A Premium Brain Supplement For Improving Memory And Focus

      Alpha Brain – A Premium Brain Supplement For Improving Memory And Focus

      Alpha Brain is a nutritional supplement, not a medicine. The chemicals in Alpha Brain are among the most powerful cognitive enhancers available.

    • Irocit – Use, Dosage And Side Effects

      Irocit – Use, Dosage And Side Effects

      Irocit is an iron, folic acid, and zinc preparation that is taken orally and is used to treat iron, folic acid, and zinc deficiency.

    • The Ability Of Kalanchoe Tubiflora To Fight Cancer

      The Ability Of Kalanchoe Tubiflora To Fight Cancer

      Kalanchoe tubiflora has a possible anti-cancer agent that stops cells from dividing and makes them less likely to live.

    • Angel Number Birthday - Represents Completion And Rebirth

      Angel Number Birthday - Represents Completion And Rebirth

      Angel Number Birthday meaning is always spiritual, and it denotes, among other things, the beginning of a season of completing things.

    • Angel Number 33 Means - Being Creative And Expressing Oneself

      Angel Number 33 Means - Being Creative And Expressing Oneself

      Angel Number 33 Is known as a "Master Number," which indicates it has a greater vibration than other numbers.